Posted by Derek Plante (derek.plante@…>)
Hi Clark,
Yes, correct in theory, but in practice with no forestay when gybing, it is simplicity itself to let it billow forwards so that it does not go near the mast. It would be bit different perhaps if one tacked through the wind from broad reach to broad reach.
I would also certainly be interested to compare the gunmount spinnaker, with a gennaker in a race!
But… I am only aware of 3 other Freedom 21’s in Australia, one in Sydney Harbour about 12 years ago, there is one currently on Brisbane Waters, Gosford, NSW (next big Lake south from us). And there is one owned by forum member Nick Wiederman in Melbourne, Victoria; but his is a lift keel.
So perhaps we will have to wait until there is one with a gennaker in the US, or else I will have to pack my sail on my next trip to the USA!
PS. My F21 was actually built by South Coast Yachts at Dapto in NSW, to “Survey” standards as it was, I believe, originally owned by a sailing school. I assume that the others were also built by South Coast, but I have never been able to find out the total number built.
Best regards,
Derek Plante.— On Wed, 11/5/08, Clark Myers <cdmyers1@…> wrote:
From: Clark Myers <cdmyers1@…>Subject: [freedom21] Re: Spinnakers: and North GennakersTo: freedom21@yahoogroups.comDate: Wednesday, November 5, 2008, 3:57 AM
Derek,Correct me if I’m wrong…When you gybe with the gennaker you need to release one jib sheet and haul that big sail around the mast. Right?With the Hoyt gun mount you simply trim the spinnaker using the rein. The mast is not in the way. It is so easy!I do think however, that it would be interesting to see how the gennaker faired vs. the spinnaker in a head to head windward leward race. Do you know any of those other downunder F21 owners? Maybe you could arange a race to give us some comparitive data.Cheers,Clark MyersTeke’s PrideF21 #345— In freedom21@yahoogrou ps.com, Derek Plante <derek.plante@ …> wrote:>> Hi Thomas, and Clark!> > I thought that my e-mail about Gennakers might just stir up a bit of discussion! > > I fully
agree with Clark that the gunmount system was extremely clever. In fact, it was one of the main features that attracted me to the F21 when I saw the demo video at the Sydney boat show in the 80’s. However, I did not finally buy a F21 until about 10 years ago when I downsized from a Triton 28… Unfortunately the only F21 I found had no spinnaker gear at all. If it had, like Clark, I might be totally convinced about the gunmount, and I can fully understand why owners like it. But… …I was in the situation of having no gunmount or spinnaker; and had given up racing after about 25 years of 'round the cans"! So I eventually decided that the gennaker was the simpler way to go for my needs. I do disagree with Clark about gybing. I cannot see that anything could be simpler than the gennaker. Just release one sheet, pull on the other, and it is done. Far fewer lines etc than the gunmount system.
And easier than a gennaker on a conventional yacht,> because of the lack of forestay etc.> In short, if my boat had the original sail and system I would probably stick with it, particularly if racing. But if only cruising, and without any of the original gear, I would certainly still go for the gennaker.> So consider your planned use, cost out the options, and enjoy sailing a fantastic little boat!> We will all be interested to see which way you go!> > Cheers,> > Derek Plante> > “At Last” Lake Macquarie, Australia.> > — On Tue, 11/4/08, Thomas Curran <kaikouravoyager@ …> wrote:> > From: Thomas Curran <kaikouravoyager@ …>> Subject: [freedom21] Re: Spinnakers: and North Gennakers> To: freedom21@yahoogrou
ps.com> Date: Tuesday, November 4, 2008, 11:10 PM> > > > > > > Thanks Clark> I am talking to my favorite sailmaker in Vermont> I will keep you posted> T> — In freedom21@yahoogrou ps.com, “Clark Myers” <cdmyers1@ .> wrote:> >> >> > Thomas,> >> > [#-o] Newer is not always better!> >> > Derek pointed out in his original posting that while he picks up more> > speed on a beam reach with his rig over the gun mount rig; he looses> > straight down wind performance. Gibing is more difficult with a> > gennaker than with the Hoyt gun mount as well. Derek also rightly> > pointed out that his rig prevents him from entering class races (I> know,> > when was the last time there was a class race?). I would also like to> >
point out that as the Gennaker is not a reccognized F21 rig there are> no> > Portsmith Handicap numbers for open racing. I admit racing isn’t> > everybody’s cup of tea. You may just want to cruise, but rather than> > reinventing the wheel, why don’t you repair the lining on your gun> mount> > and try the spinnaker rig? You might even like it if you try it!> > [=D>] After all Garry Hoyt is a genious!> >> > The www.fredom21. info <http://www.fredom21 .info> site has links to> > several sailmakers who make or have made F21 sails.> >> > Clark Myers> >> > Teke’s Pride> >> > F21 #345> >> >> > — In freedom21@yahoogrou ps.com, “Thomas Curran” kaikouravoyager@> > wrote:> >
Good On Ya Mate [:)]> > > Thanks for the info. 23 years have passed since the gun mount> concept,> > > the new sail setups are the way to go.> > > I do have the carbon mast will do as you say> > > Faster is better!> > > T> > > — In freedom21@yahoogrou ps.com, Derek Plante derek.plante@ wrote:> > > >> > > > Hi Thomas,> > > >> > > > I used the aluminium Selden pole number 072-072-70. This is 2080mm> > > long x 72 mill diameter. I shortened it to about 1500mm so that it> > > stores neatly in the retracted position between the bow fitting and> > just> > > to starboard of the mast. The slight offset to starboard also allows> > the> > > pole to clear the mooring cleat. This size still gives approx
700mm> > > extension from the bow when extended, which the local Selden> > distributor> > > reckoned was about ideal.> > > > I would have liked the carbon pole but baulked at the high price> > > (approx 4x the alloy!)> > > > As for the sail dimensions, I will check these and get back to> you.> > > But I stress that my boat was built in Austraila with Alloy mast; so> > may> > > differ from USA factory dimensions. So it would be essential to> > measure> > > your own boat, after fitting the bowsprit, before any sailmaking.> > > > I have never sailed a Freedom with the standard gun mount> spinnaker> > so> > > cannot compare ultimate performance. But I am happy with the> > performance> > > of the gennaker; and it certainly is very
simple to fit and handle,> > (the> > > Snuffer is invaluable). It also is much simpler, avoiding the miles> of> > > line that are needed for the GunMount system.> > > >> > > > Happy sailing,> > > >> > > > Derek Plante.> > > >> > > > "At Last " 209, Lake Macquarie, NSW Australia.> > > >> > > > — On Sun, 11/2/08, Thomas Curran kaikouravoyager@ wrote:> > > >> > > > From: Thomas Curran kaikouravoyager@> > > > Subject: [freedom21] Re: Spinnakers: and North Gennakers> > > > To: freedom21@yahoogrou ps.com> > > > Date: Sunday, November 2, 2008, 5:26 PM> > > >> > > >> > > >> > > >> > > >> > > >> > >
Derek> > > > Which Selden spar did you use, Carbon or aluminum? and which> > > dimension.> > > > I have downloaded there pdf file for choices> > > > Thanks> > > > Tom> > > > — In freedom21@yahoogrou ps.com, “derek.plante” <derek.plante@> > …>> > > > wrote:> > > > >> > > > > Hi All,> > > > >> > > > > I have noted some recent discussion on the F21 Forum about> > > > > spinnakers. Can I add a different point of view as seen from> “Down> > > > > Under”!> > > > > My F21 “At Last” is one of only 4 Freedoms that I am aware of in> > > > > Australia. I have owned it now for about 10 years.> > > > > It is unusual in having an aluminium mast by
Spunspar in Sydney;> > and> > > > > it was never fitted with the gunmount spinnaker.> > > > >> > > > > For years I procrastinated about fitting a spinnaker, until my> son> > > > > Julian who works for North Sails in Sydney, suggested that a> > > simpler,> > > > > and cheaper option would be to go for a gennaker flown from one> of> > > > > the new Selden retractable bowsprits.> > > > >> > > > > We just finished fitting this rig a couple of weeks ago, and> have> > > now> > > > > sailed with it 3 times. Verdict is great! Extremely simple to> fit,> > > > > and very easy to hoist and drop using North’s clever “Snuffer”.> > Only> > > > > possible drawbacks are
that it is obviously not legal for F21> > Class> > > > > racing, which we do not have in Australia; and that one cannot> > sail> > > > > as square as with conventional spinnaker. This necessitates a> bit> > of> > > > > downwind tacking, which is fun as the boat is dead easy to gybe.> > > > > For anyone interested, the Selden pole is not cheap, but is very> > > well> > > > > designed, and constructed, and worth the cost. We used their> > > smallest> > > > > pole (2 meters long), and shortened it to approx 1.5 meters.> This> > is> > > > > about the right length to be able to store the retracted pole on> > > deck> > > > > between the bow and mast; and gives approx 700mm extension>
beyond> > > the> > > > > bow when extended through the special ring bowfitting.> > > > > We also fitted an new North mainsail with a loose foot, this> > > > > is also a big improvement, with much better and more accurate> > > control> > > > > of sailshape with the outhaul, compared to the previous bolt> rope.> > > > >> > > > > I have just added photos of the rig to the “At Last” section of> > the> > > > > photos page on this F21 Forum site.> > > > >> > > > > Derek Plante.> > > > > “At Last”, Lake Macquarie, New South Wales, Australia.> > > > >> > > >> > >> >>